Are Startup Valuations Finally Coming Back to Earth?

Are Startup Valuations Finally Coming Back to Earth?

Are Startup Valuations Finally Coming Back to Earth?

In today’s episode of Strap On Your Boots, I explore whether startup valuations are becoming more realistic and why raising venture capital remains so difficult for entrepreneurs without established investor connections. Drawing from fifteen years of building technology companies, including Spinnr, Vengo AI, and Campus Pixel, I share my experiences pitching investors, struggling to meet constantly changing expectations, and watching heavily funded startups receive opportunities that smaller founders rarely get. I also discuss why revenue, capital efficiency, and real customer traction should matter more than hype, and how even successful bootstrapped companies can struggle to scale without investment. As the venture capital market evolves, I question whether investors are truly becoming more disciplined or simply making it harder for overlooked founders to access the funding they need.

Listen to the Podcast:

Get ready to strap on your boots. I’m your host, Jason Sherman. Today I want to talk about startup valuations, venture capital, and something I’ve been dealing with personally for more than a decade. There’s been a lot of discussion lately about whether startup valuations are finally coming back down to earth, especially after years of watching companies raise enormous amounts of money based on what they might eventually become. And as somebody who’s been building technology companies and pitching investors for roughly fifteen years, I have some pretty strong feelings about this because I’ve experienced what it’s like to build a company without that kind of financial backing.

I remember when I first started pitching investors for companies like Picklify and Instamour. We were building real technology, developing products, trying to attract users, and doing everything we thought entrepreneurs were supposed to do. We would attend pitch events, meet with potential investors, put together presentations, and explain why we believed our companies had the potential to become successful businesses. And almost every conversation eventually came back to the same questions. How many users do you have? How much revenue are you generating? What’s your growth rate? How are you going to monetize the platform?

Those are perfectly reasonable questions, and I understand why investors ask them. If somebody is going to put a substantial amount of money into a company, they want to know there’s a realistic opportunity to make that money back. But what always frustrated me was how much pressure there was to make everything sound bigger than it actually was.

If we had a hundred thousand registered users, for example, there was pressure to present those numbers in the most impressive way possible. You’d hear people talking about daily active users or monthly active users, and suddenly the distinction between somebody who had signed up for your platform and somebody who was actively using it became incredibly important. We sometimes rationalized presenting those numbers more favorably than the actual activity justified because we were growing and believed we’d eventually reach those milestones.

Looking back, I can recognize why that’s a problem. An investor needs to understand what those numbers actually represent. But when you’re a founder who’s desperately trying to raise capital, and you’re surrounded by other startups making enormous claims about their growth, you start feeling like you have to compete with those claims just to get somebody’s attention.

I remember another experience with Instamour when we were participating in the StartFast Accelerator. We had built this video dating platform, and we were focused on attracting users and improving the experience. But the accelerator was encouraging us to introduce monetization because investors wanted to see that somebody would actually pay for the product.

So we spent a considerable amount of time developing a paid feature. We had to design it, program it, test it, and integrate it into the application. And eventually, somebody paid ninety-nine cents to use it.

Now, from a technical standpoint, that was an accomplishment. We had demonstrated that the platform could process a payment and that at least one person was willing to spend money on a feature. But we were also hoping that this would become a compelling argument for investors. We figured that if one person was willing to pay, then potentially thousands or millions of users might eventually do the same thing.

Of course, that’s a pretty enormous assumption when you think about it. One person spending a dollar doesn’t establish that you have a sustainable business model. But at the time, we were trying to demonstrate progress in whatever way we could.

And after all that work, it didn’t really change our fundraising situation. Investors still wanted more users, more revenue, more traction, and more evidence that the business could scale.

That experience stayed with me because I started noticing a pattern throughout my entrepreneurial career. Every time we reached a milestone that we thought would make the company more attractive to investors, the expectations seemed to move a little further away.

We’d build the product, and they’d want users. We’d get users, and they’d want revenue. We’d generate revenue, and they’d want faster growth. And eventually, you start wondering what it actually takes to convince somebody that you’ve built something worth investing in.

Especially when you’re watching other startups announce funding rounds worth millions of dollars before they’ve even launched a product.

And that’s where I think the venture capital world becomes really interesting, because when you look at the companies that receive enormous amounts of funding, there’s often a story behind those investments that the rest of us never hear about. You might read an article about a startup that raised twenty million dollars before launching its first product, and naturally, you start wondering how they managed to convince investors to take that kind of risk.

But then you look into the founders’ backgrounds, and you sometimes discover that they attended Stanford or Harvard, worked at Google or Facebook, or previously founded a company that was acquired. They might have spent years building relationships with investors, or maybe one of their former colleagues is now a partner at a venture capital firm. Those connections can make an enormous difference when you’re trying to get a meeting, and even more of a difference when you’re trying to convince somebody to write a check.

I’ve experienced the other side of that situation for most of my entrepreneurial career. I didn’t graduate from an Ivy League university, and I didn’t spend ten years working at Google before starting my first company. I built my career by creating things, learning technology, starting businesses, making mistakes, and figuring out how to keep moving forward when something didn’t work.

And I’ve spent years trying to prove that experience matters.

When I walk into an investor meeting, I feel like I have to justify practically everything. I have to explain the technology, demonstrate that the product works, show that we have customers, explain the business model, introduce the team, and provide evidence that there’s an actual market for what we’re building. And again, I understand why investors want that information. I’d want to know those things too if I were investing my own money.

What frustrates me is the feeling that some founders are given the benefit of the doubt because of their backgrounds, while others have to demonstrate considerably more before they’re taken seriously.

Now, I can’t say that every founder who attended Stanford gets funded, or that every investor makes decisions based on somebody’s résumé. That’s obviously not true. Plenty of well-connected founders struggle to raise capital, and plenty of entrepreneurs without those connections eventually succeed. But relationships and credibility play a major role in venture capital, and I think founders who aren’t already part of those networks face an additional challenge.

And the frustrating part is that even after you’ve spent years building companies and demonstrating that you can generate revenue, that challenge doesn’t necessarily disappear.

Take what we’re doing today with Vengo AI and Campus Pixel. These are functioning technology platforms with actual customers. We’re working with organizations that include Fortune 500 companies and universities. We’ve already invested the time and resources required to build the technology, test it, and demonstrate that businesses are willing to pay for what we’re offering.

We’re also operating with a relatively small team. We have roughly eight people involved across our businesses, and we’re doing work that might require considerably larger teams at other companies.

When I look at what we’ve accomplished with those resources, I’m proud of it. We’ve managed to build products, attract customers, generate contracts, and continue improving the technology without having millions of dollars sitting in a bank account.

But there’s a limit to how quickly you can grow when you’re funding practically everything through your own operations.

And this is where I think people sometimes misunderstand what entrepreneurs like me are looking for when we approach investors. We’re not necessarily asking somebody to give us millions of dollars so we can spend the next two years figuring out whether an idea is worth pursuing. We’ve already done a lot of that work. We have functioning products, paying customers, and evidence that organizations are interested in what we’re building.

What we need is the ability to reach more of those customers.

Right now, we have roughly two or three people involved in selling our products, and even with that limited sales capacity, we’ve been able to pursue and secure contracts worth hundreds of thousands of dollars over time. That’s encouraging, especially when you consider how long enterprise sales cycles can be.

But imagine what happens when you’re competing against companies that have fifty or a hundred employees, substantial marketing budgets, and dedicated sales departments. They’re able to attend more conferences, contact more prospects, run larger advertising campaigns, and maintain relationships with far more potential customers than a small team can realistically handle.

And that’s the opportunity I keep coming back to when I think about what outside investment could mean for our companies.

If somebody invested five million dollars into our companies tomorrow, I already have a pretty good idea of where that money would go. We wouldn’t need to spend years building the technology because we’ve already built it. We wouldn’t need to spend a fortune trying to determine whether there’s a market because we’re already selling to customers in that market. Most of that investment would go toward expanding our sales operation, increasing our marketing efforts, and giving our existing development team the resources to continue improving the platforms.

And when I say expanding sales, I’m talking about hiring people who can spend their entire day finding potential customers, scheduling demonstrations, building relationships, and closing contracts. We could create a sales organization with twenty people instead of relying on the two or three people who are currently handling most of that responsibility.

Of course, hiring twenty salespeople doesn’t automatically mean you’ll generate ten times as much revenue. You still have to find the right people, train them, develop a repeatable sales process, and make sure the economics of acquiring customers actually work. Some salespeople will perform better than others, and enterprise contracts can take months to close regardless of how many people you have making calls.

But we already have a starting point. We’ve demonstrated that we can sell these products with very limited resources, and I’d like the opportunity to find out how much further we could take them with a properly funded sales operation.

And that’s where my frustration with venture capital comes from. I’ve spent roughly fifteen years building businesses, learning how to develop technology, attracting customers, and figuring out how to generate revenue. I’m approaching fifty years old, and I’ve been trying to prove myself as an entrepreneur since I was around thirty.

At some point, you start wondering how much more evidence somebody needs before they’re willing to take a chance on you.

And then I see stories about companies that raised hundreds of millions of dollars, only to eventually shut down or sell their assets for a fraction of what investors put into them. I always find those stories frustrating because I think about how much could have been accomplished with that capital if it had been invested differently.

Now, I understand that venture capital involves risk. Investors know that some companies are going to fail, and they’re hoping the successful investments will generate enough returns to compensate for those losses. That’s the business model, and I don’t have a problem with that.

But I do question whether the industry sometimes places too much emphasis on a founder’s background, the excitement surrounding a particular market, or the possibility of an enormous exit, while overlooking entrepreneurs who have already demonstrated that they can build and operate real businesses.

And that brings us back to startup valuations.

For years, we watched companies raise money at valuations that seemed almost impossible to justify based on their actual financial performance. Investors were willing to pay enormous premiums for the possibility of future growth, particularly when money was relatively inexpensive and everyone was competing to invest in the next major technology company.

Now we’re seeing a more complicated environment. Investors are paying closer attention to revenue, profitability, capital efficiency, and whether companies can realistically justify their valuations. At least in some parts of the market, the days of raising money simply because you have an exciting idea appear to be much more difficult.

I think some of that scrutiny is healthy. Companies should be able to explain how they intend to make money, and founders should understand the financial realities of operating their businesses.

But I also think there’s an important distinction between a company being overvalued and a company being underfunded.

A startup might be worth considerably less than its founders believe, while still having a legitimate opportunity to grow with additional investment. And a company with a modest valuation might actually be a much better investment than one that’s attracting headlines because somebody assigned it a billion-dollar price tag.

There’s also the question of how much capital companies really need today. With modern development tools, cloud infrastructure, and artificial intelligence, entrepreneurs can accomplish things with relatively small teams that would have required substantially more money fifteen years ago.

I’ve experienced that transformation myself. We’re building and maintaining sophisticated platforms with a fraction of the workforce we once needed. That should change how investors evaluate the amount of funding required to reach certain milestones.

But cheaper development doesn’t necessarily mean cheaper growth. You still have to find customers, build relationships, support those customers, and convince organizations to trust your technology. And in enterprise sales, those things take time and money.

So when people ask whether startup valuations are finally coming back to earth, I think it’s worth asking what that actually means for entrepreneurs.

If investors become more disciplined about where they put their money, that could be a positive development. But if that discipline simply means making it even harder for founders without established connections to access capital, I’m not sure we’ve solved the underlying problem.

I still believe there’s enormous potential in the companies we’re building. I see it in the customers we’re working with, the contracts we’re securing, and the conversations we’re having with organizations that need the technology we’ve developed.

And I still want the opportunity to take one of those companies to a much larger scale. I’ve already experienced what it’s like to build slowly, operate with limited resources, and accomplish as much as possible with a small team. I’d like to experience what happens when we finally have the capital to pursue the market at the scale I believe is possible.

Maybe startup valuations are becoming more realistic. Maybe investors are learning from some of the mistakes made during previous funding cycles. I hope that’s the case.

But I’d also like to see the venture capital industry take a closer look at founders who have spent years doing the actual work of building companies, even when they haven’t had the financial backing or professional connections that make fundraising easier.

Because somewhere out there, I’m sure there are plenty of entrepreneurs who have already built something valuable and are still trying to figure out how to get the resources they need to grow it.

And I suspect that conversation about who gets funded, and why, is going to continue long after the current debate about startup valuations settles down.

 

jasonsherman Avatar

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.

Insert the contact form shortcode with the additional CSS class- "wydegrid-newsletter-section"

By signing up, you agree to the our terms and our Privacy Policy agreement.